The Phillies' pitching woes were on full display in their recent blowout loss to the Reds, highlighting a critical issue that could hinder their playoff hopes. With a staggering 25 pitchers used this season, the team's depth and reliability in the rotation are cause for concern.
One of the key players in this narrative is Alan Rangel, a right-hander who struggled in his limited starts. His 4.19 ERA in 19 1/3 innings is respectable, but the fact that he's pitched four or fewer innings in four games puts immense pressure on the bullpen. This is especially true when you consider the team's strategy of planning for bullpen games, indicating a lack of a reliable No. 5 starter while Andrew Painter recovers in Triple-A Lehigh Valley.
The Phillies' decision to recall Rangel and place Lou Trivino on the injured list underscores the team's current predicament. Rangel's performance, including a game-tying home run to Sal Stewart in the third inning and a go-ahead homer to Noelvi Marte in the fourth, further emphasized the team's pitching struggles.
Tanner Banks, acquired from the White Sox, also had a challenging night. His 3.07 ERA from last year, which earned him a trusted role in high-leverage situations, has taken a significant dip this season. With a 5.86 ERA and three consecutive home runs to Elly De La Cruz, Stewart, and JJ Bleday, Banks' performance has raised eyebrows. The last time a Phillies pitcher allowed three consecutive homers in an inning was in 2022, a stark reminder of the team's recent struggles.
The situation is dire, with José Alvarado, another left-hander, allowing four runs in the sixth inning. Alvarado's 7.03 ERA and the highest BABIP (.437) of any reliever in the past 50 years suggest a hint of poor luck, but the team's overall performance is concerning. Banks and Alvarado join a small group of pitchers with a 7.00 ERA or higher, a situation that hasn't been seen since 1999.
The Phillies' struggles extend to other left-handed relievers as well, with Kyle Backhus optioned to make room for Max Lazar. Backhus' 5.87 ERA in 17 appearances is a testament to the team's pitching woes. The combined ERA of Alvarado, Banks, and Backhus is a staggering 6.84, with a 1.82 WHIP and a .921 OPS against, further highlighting the team's defensive challenges.
Amidst this turmoil, Tim Mayza stands out as a beacon of hope, with a 2.81 ERA in 36 appearances. However, the team's overall pitching struggles and the need for reliable starters and relievers cannot be overstated. The Phillies' playoff aspirations will be significantly impacted by their ability to address these pitching concerns and find consistent performances from their pitchers.
